Smithing: Difference between revisions

From Kintara
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Sirlym (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Cap 40, not counted in Total Level, no unlock gate; per-ingot smelting, per-tool levels, durability 4,000/2,500 (content audit)
Line 5: Line 5:
| tool          = Frostmere forge · Dunes West forge
| tool          = Frostmere forge · Dunes West forge
| xp_per_action = Varies by item (see tables below)
| xp_per_action = Varies by item (see tables below)
| max_level    = At least 30 (exact new cap unconfirmed since the Total Level cap rose from 30 to 40)
| max_level    = 40 (same cap as every skill)
| counts_total  = Yes (updated see note below)
| counts_total  = No Smithing does not count toward Total Level
}}
}}
'''Smithing''' was overhauled in the Dunes update (v5.3). The old single "Lvl 2 tool" upgrade track has been replaced with a full '''copper → iron → silver''' ore-tier progression covering both tools and armor. Smithing unlocks at [[Total Level]] 20 and is forged identically at [[Grimjaw]]'s anvil in [[Frostmere]] or [[Harun the Forgewright|Harun]]'s forge in [[Dunes West]].
'''Smithing''' was overhauled in the Dunes update (v5.3). The old single "Lvl 2 tool" upgrade track has been replaced with a full '''copper → iron → silver''' ore-tier progression covering both tools and armor. There is no Total Level requirement to start Smithing — each recipe is gated only by your Smithing level. Forging is identical at [[Grimjaw]]'s anvil in [[Frostmere]] or [[Harun the Forgewright|Harun]]'s forge in [[Dunes West]].


<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> This page previously described the old "Lvl 2 Axe/Pickaxe/Sword via Metal" system, which counted Smithing as a bonus track that did not count toward Total Level. That system has been retired. Smithing is now one of the 6 core tracked skills (alongside Fishing, Cooking, Combat, Mining, Woodcutting), and unlocking it requires Total Level 20 — confirm in-game whether Smithing itself now contributes back to your Total Level.</div>
<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> This page previously described the old "Lvl 2 Axe/Pickaxe/Sword via Metal" system. That system has been retired. Smithing is now a fully tracked skill alongside Fishing, Cooking, Combat, Mining, and Woodcutting — but it remains the bonus sixth skill: it does '''not''' count toward your [[Total Level]].</div>


== Unlocking ==
== Unlocking ==
Line 17: Line 17:
! Detail
! Detail
|-
|-
| Total Level 20
| No unlock gate
| Required to unlock Smithing
| Smithing has no Total Level requirement — each recipe is gated by your Smithing level (see tables below)
|-
|-
| Forge locations
| Forge locations
Line 25: Line 25:


== Smelting ==
== Smelting ==
Smelting converts raw ore into ingots. No Smithing level requirement to smelt.
Smelting converts raw ore into ingots. No Smithing level requirement to smelt. Smelts are priced per ingot and can be batched ×1, ×5, or ×10 (10 max per batch).


<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> Smelting used to take 30 seconds per ingot. It's now '''1 second per ingot''', and the forge supports batch smelting — ×1, ×5, or ×10 on any stackable smelt, same batching system already used for tool forging.</div>
<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> Smelting used to take 30 seconds per pour. It's now about '''1 second per ingot''', and the forge supports batch smelting — ×1, ×5, or ×10 on any stackable smelt.</div>


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! Ingot
! Ingot
! Materials
! Materials per ingot
! Yield
! XP per ingot
! XP
! Time per ingot
! Time per ingot
|-
|-
| Copper Ingot
| Copper Ingot
| 100 [[Stone]] + 50 [[Coal]]
| 10 [[Stone]] + 5 [[Coal]]
| 10 ingots
| 10 XP
| 100 XP
| ~1 second
| 1 second
|-
|-
| Iron Ingot
| Iron Ingot
| 60 [[Iron Ore]] + 60 [[Coal]]
| 6 [[Iron Ore]] + 6 [[Coal]]
| 10 ingots
| 22 XP
| 220 XP
| ~1 second
| 1 second
|-
|-
| Silver Ingot
| Silver Ingot
| 40 [[Silver Ore]] + 80 [[Coal]]
| 4 [[Silver Ore]] + 8 [[Coal]]
| 10 ingots
| 30 XP
| 450 XP
| ~1 second
| 1 second
|}
|}
A ×10 batch therefore pays 100/220/300 XP for copper/iron/silver. (The 450 XP figure previously listed for silver was never the rate — the old fixed pour paid 300.)


== Forging Tools ==
== Forging Tools ==
Tools are crafted from scratch — no base tool is consumed. Forge cooldown is '''30 seconds''' per craft (reduced from the original 60 seconds).
Tools are crafted from scratch — no base tool is consumed. Forging now shares the same ~1-second-per-unit pace as smelting (reduced from the earlier 30-second cooldown).
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! Tier
! Tier
! Tool
! Smithing level
! Smithing level
! Tool
! Materials
! Materials
! XP
! XP
|-
|-
| rowspan="3" | Copper
| rowspan="3" | Copper
| rowspan="3" | 0–7
| [[Copper Axe]]
| [[Copper Axe]]
| 0
| 20 Copper Ingots + 400 [[Wood]]
| 20 Copper Ingots + 400 [[Wood]]
| 400 XP
| 400 XP
|-
|-
| [[Copper Sword]]
| [[Copper Sword]]
| 3
| 25 Copper Ingots + 600 [[Wood]]
| 25 Copper Ingots + 600 [[Wood]]
| 400 XP
| 400 XP
|-
|-
| [[Copper Pickaxe]]
| [[Copper Pickaxe]]
| 7
| 28 Copper Ingots + 850 [[Wood]]
| 28 Copper Ingots + 850 [[Wood]]
| 400 XP
| 400 XP
|-
|-
| rowspan="3" | Iron
| rowspan="3" | Iron
| rowspan="3" | 10–17
| [[Iron Axe]]
| [[Iron Axe]]
| 10
| 40 Iron Ingots + 1,000 [[Wood]]
| 40 Iron Ingots + 1,000 [[Wood]]
| 750 XP
| 750 XP
|-
|-
| [[Iron Sword]]
| [[Iron Sword]]
| 13
| 55 Iron Ingots + 1,300 [[Wood]]
| 55 Iron Ingots + 1,300 [[Wood]]
| 750 XP
| 750 XP
|-
|-
| [[Iron Pickaxe]]
| [[Iron Pickaxe]]
| 17
| 60 Iron Ingots + 1,600 [[Wood]]
| 60 Iron Ingots + 1,600 [[Wood]]
| 750 XP
| 750 XP
|-
|-
| rowspan="3" | Silver
| rowspan="3" | Silver
| rowspan="3" | 20–27
| [[Silver Axe]]
| [[Silver Axe]]
| 20
| 80 Silver Ingots + 2,000 [[Wood]]
| 80 Silver Ingots + 2,000 [[Wood]]
| 1,100 XP
| 700 XP
|-
|-
| [[Silver Sword]]
| [[Silver Sword]]
| 23
| 90 Silver Ingots + 2,500 [[Wood]]
| 90 Silver Ingots + 2,500 [[Wood]]
| 1,100 XP
| 700 XP
|-
|-
| [[Silver Pickaxe]]
| [[Silver Pickaxe]]
| 27
| 100 Silver Ingots + 3,000 [[Wood]]
| 100 Silver Ingots + 3,000 [[Wood]]
| 1,100 XP
| 700 XP
|}
|}


Line 115: Line 119:
| Starter
| Starter
| 5
| 5
| —
| — (never wears)
|-
|-
| Copper
| Copper
| 23
| 23
| 7,000 uses
| 4,000 uses
|-
|-
| Iron
| Iron
| 26
| 26
| 7,000 uses
| 4,000 uses
|-
|-
| Silver
| Silver
| 30
| 30
| 7,000 uses
| 4,000 uses
|}
|}
''Strength Potion adds a flat +10 damage on top of any tier.''
''Strength Potion adds a flat +10 damage on top of any tier.''


<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Correction — Balance Pass:</span> Starter sword damage was previously listed as 20, close enough to Copper's 23 that the first rung of the weapon ladder was pointless. It has been corrected to '''5'''. This is a fix to the number itself, not a new nerf — the design intent was always for Starter to sit well below Copper, and the old figure on this page was wrong. Copper (23), Iron (26), and Silver (30) are unchanged.</div>
Tool tiers do '''not''' change gathering yield or XP — every tier gathers 1 per swing and grants the same skill XP. What a higher tier buys is swing speed: copper swings 5% faster, iron 10% faster, and silver 15% faster than the starter tool.
 
<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Correction — Balance Pass:</span> Starter sword damage was previously listed as 20, close enough to Copper's 23 that the first rung of the weapon ladder was pointless. It has been corrected to '''5'''. This is a fix to the number itself, not a new nerf — the design intent was always for Starter to sit well below Copper, and the old figure on this page was wrong. Copper (23), Iron (26), and Silver (30) are unchanged. Tool durability was separately rebalanced from 7,000 to '''4,000''' in a 2026-08-31 update.</div>


== Armor Crafting ==
== Armor Crafting ==
Line 146: Line 152:
| 14
| 14
| 40 Iron Ingots + 40 Molten Rock + 5 [[Brute Horn]]
| 40 Iron Ingots + 40 Molten Rock + 5 [[Brute Horn]]
| 400 XP
| 280 XP
|-
|-
| Body
| Body
| 20
| 20
| 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 500 XP
| 350 XP
|-
|-
| Legguards
| Legguards
| 18
| 18
| 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 500 XP
| 350 XP
|-
|-
| Boots
| Boots
| 16
| 16
| 25 Iron Ingots + 25 Molten Rock + 2 [[Brute Horn]]
| 25 Iron Ingots + 25 Molten Rock + 2 [[Brute Horn]]
| 250 XP
| 175 XP
|-
|-
| '''Full set'''
| '''Full set'''
| —
| —
| '''165 Iron Ingots + 165 Molten Rock + 27 Brute Horn'''
| '''165 Iron Ingots + 165 Molten Rock + 27 Brute Horn'''
| '''1,650 XP'''
| '''1,155 XP'''
|}
|}
Armor XP is 7 XP per ingot in the recipe.


=== Silver Armor (requires Combat 25 to wear) ===
=== Silver Armor (requires Combat 25 to wear) ===
Line 179: Line 187:
| 24
| 24
| 80 Silver Ingots + 60 Molten Rock + 15 [[Brute Horn]]
| 80 Silver Ingots + 60 Molten Rock + 15 [[Brute Horn]]
| 800 XP
| 560 XP
|-
|-
| Body
| Body
| 28
| 30
| ~6 Silver Ingots + ~26 Molten Rock + 4 [[Brute Horn]] <ref>Figure as recorded — unusually low relative to Helmet/Boots cost. Verify in-game before treating as final.</ref>
| 100 Silver Ingots + 80 Molten Rock + 25 [[Brute Horn]]
| 1,000 XP
| 700 XP
|-
|-
| Legguards
| Legguards
| 26
| 28
| ~5 Silver Ingots + ~24 Molten Rock + 4 [[Brute Horn]] <ref>Figure as recorded — unusually low relative to Helmet/Boots cost. Verify in-game before treating as final.</ref>
| 75 Silver Ingots + 70 Molten Rock + 25 [[Brute Horn]]
| 750 XP
| 525 XP
|-
|-
| Boots
| Boots
| 24
| 26
| 40 Silver Ingots + 20 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 40 Silver Ingots + 20 Molten Rock + 10 [[Brute Horn]]
| 400 XP
| 280 XP
|-
|-
| '''Full set'''
| '''Full set'''
| —
| —
| '''~18 Silver Ingots + Molten Rock/Brute Horn (see note)'''
| '''295 Silver Ingots + 230 Molten Rock + 75 Brute Horn'''
| '''2,950 XP'''
| '''2,065 XP'''
|}
|}


<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Verify:</span> Silver Body and Legguards ingot costs look out of line with the rest of the table (far lower than Helmet or Boots despite higher XP). Recommend re-checking these at the forge before treating them as confirmed.</div>
Armor durability: '''2,500 uses per piece''' (rebalanced from 1,000 in a 2026-08-31 update) — each worn piece spends 1 durability per hit taken. Repair cost is roughly 60% of the original craft cost, scaled to damage taken (minimum 1 ingot).
 
Armor durability: '''1,000 uses per piece'''. Repair cost is roughly 60% of the original craft cost, scaled to damage taken (minimum 1 ingot).


== Batch Crafting ==
== Batch Crafting ==
<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> The forge supports batch crafting for both tool/armor forging and smelting — pick a quantity (×1, ×5, or ×10) and the anvil works through it automatically instead of requiring a click per craft.</div>
<div class="kin-note"><span class="kin-note-label">Update:</span> The forge supports batch crafting for smelting — pick a quantity (×1, ×5, or ×10) and the anvil works through it automatically instead of requiring a click per craft.</div>
* Tool and armor forging: each individual craft still takes its full 30 seconds — a ×10 batch takes 10x as long, not shorter.
* Batching applies to stackable smelts; forged tools and armor craft one per request.
* Smelting: each individual ingot now takes 1 second — a ×10 batch of smelting takes roughly 10 seconds.
* Each unit takes roughly 1 second — a ×10 batch of smelting takes roughly 10 seconds.
* If materials run out mid-batch, crafting stops and tells you — no partial-consumption surprises.
* If materials run out mid-batch, crafting stops and tells you — no partial-consumption surprises.
* Closing the forge window cancels anything not yet started, at no material cost.
* Closing the forge window cancels anything not yet started, at no material cost.
Line 222: Line 228:


== Tips ==
== Tips ==
* Smelt ingots in bulk before forging sessions — at 1 second per ingot with ×10 batching, stockpiling is nearly instant now compared to the old 30-second rate.
* Smelt ingots in bulk before forging sessions — at about 1 second per ingot with ×10 batching, stockpiling is nearly instant now compared to the old 30-second rate.
* Iron and Silver tools require reaching the relevant Smithing level before you can forge them — level up gradually through Copper tools/armor first.
* Iron and Silver tools require reaching the relevant Smithing level before you can forge them — level up gradually through Copper tools/armor first.
* Armor now grants real XP on craft (previously a dead end), so don't skip crafting a full set purely for the XP even if you don't plan to wear it yet.
* Armor grants real XP on craft, so a full set is worth forging for the XP even if you don't plan to wear it yet.
* Keep gear undamaged if you intend to trade or sell it — repair before listing.
* Keep gear undamaged if you intend to trade or sell it — repair before listing.
* Don't confuse Starter sword's low 5 damage for a bug — it's an intentional correction meant to make the Copper upgrade feel meaningful.
* Don't confuse Starter sword's low 5 damage for a bug — it's an intentional correction meant to make the Copper upgrade feel meaningful.
* Tool tiers buy swing speed only — pick the tier your Smithing level allows, but don't expect bigger yields or more XP per gather.


{{Skills (navbox)}}
{{Skills (navbox)}}
[[Category:Skills]]
[[Category:Skills]]
[[Category:The Dunes]]
[[Category:The Dunes]]

Revision as of 19:49, 10 September 2026

Smithing (Skill)
Activity Smelting ore into ingots, forging Copper/Iron/Silver tools and armor at Grimjaw (Frostmere) or Harun (Dunes West)
Tool required Frostmere forge · Dunes West forge
XP per action Varies by item (see tables below)
Max level 40 (same cap as every skill)
Counts to Total Level No — Smithing does not count toward Total Level

Smithing was overhauled in the Dunes update (v5.3). The old single "Lvl 2 tool" upgrade track has been replaced with a full copper → iron → silver ore-tier progression covering both tools and armor. There is no Total Level requirement to start Smithing — each recipe is gated only by your Smithing level. Forging is identical at Grimjaw's anvil in Frostmere or Harun's forge in Dunes West.

Update: This page previously described the old "Lvl 2 Axe/Pickaxe/Sword via Metal" system. That system has been retired. Smithing is now a fully tracked skill alongside Fishing, Cooking, Combat, Mining, and Woodcutting — but it remains the bonus sixth skill: it does not count toward your Total Level.

Unlocking

Requirement Detail
No unlock gate Smithing has no Total Level requirement — each recipe is gated by your Smithing level (see tables below)
Forge locations Grimjaw in Frostmere · Harun the Forgewright in Dunes West (identical service)

Smelting

Smelting converts raw ore into ingots. No Smithing level requirement to smelt. Smelts are priced per ingot and can be batched ×1, ×5, or ×10 (10 max per batch).

Update: Smelting used to take 30 seconds per pour. It's now about 1 second per ingot, and the forge supports batch smelting — ×1, ×5, or ×10 on any stackable smelt.
Ingot Materials per ingot XP per ingot Time per ingot
Copper Ingot 10 Stone + 5 Coal 10 XP ~1 second
Iron Ingot 6 Iron Ore + 6 Coal 22 XP ~1 second
Silver Ingot 4 Silver Ore + 8 Coal 30 XP ~1 second

A ×10 batch therefore pays 100/220/300 XP for copper/iron/silver. (The 450 XP figure previously listed for silver was never the rate — the old fixed pour paid 300.)

Forging Tools

Tools are crafted from scratch — no base tool is consumed. Forging now shares the same ~1-second-per-unit pace as smelting (reduced from the earlier 30-second cooldown).

Tier Tool Smithing level Materials XP
Copper Copper Axe 0 20 Copper Ingots + 400 Wood 400 XP
Copper Sword 3 25 Copper Ingots + 600 Wood 400 XP
Copper Pickaxe 7 28 Copper Ingots + 850 Wood 400 XP
Iron Iron Axe 10 40 Iron Ingots + 1,000 Wood 750 XP
Iron Sword 13 55 Iron Ingots + 1,300 Wood 750 XP
Iron Pickaxe 17 60 Iron Ingots + 1,600 Wood 750 XP
Silver Silver Axe 20 80 Silver Ingots + 2,000 Wood 700 XP
Silver Sword 23 90 Silver Ingots + 2,500 Wood 700 XP
Silver Pickaxe 27 100 Silver Ingots + 3,000 Wood 700 XP

Tool Stats

Tool tier Sword damage Durability
Starter 5 — (never wears)
Copper 23 4,000 uses
Iron 26 4,000 uses
Silver 30 4,000 uses

Strength Potion adds a flat +10 damage on top of any tier.

Tool tiers do not change gathering yield or XP — every tier gathers 1 per swing and grants the same skill XP. What a higher tier buys is swing speed: copper swings 5% faster, iron 10% faster, and silver 15% faster than the starter tool.

Correction — Balance Pass: Starter sword damage was previously listed as 20, close enough to Copper's 23 that the first rung of the weapon ladder was pointless. It has been corrected to 5. This is a fix to the number itself, not a new nerf — the design intent was always for Starter to sit well below Copper, and the old figure on this page was wrong. Copper (23), Iron (26), and Silver (30) are unchanged. Tool durability was separately rebalanced from 7,000 to 4,000 in a 2026-08-31 update.

Armor Crafting

Armor is crafted under Kaziir's guidance and forged at the same blacksmiths as tools.

Iron Armor (requires Combat 15 to wear)

Piece Smithing level Materials XP
Helmet 14 40 Iron Ingots + 40 Molten Rock + 5 Brute Horn 280 XP
Body 20 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 Brute Horn 350 XP
Legguards 18 50 Iron Ingots + 50 Molten Rock + 10 Brute Horn 350 XP
Boots 16 25 Iron Ingots + 25 Molten Rock + 2 Brute Horn 175 XP
Full set 165 Iron Ingots + 165 Molten Rock + 27 Brute Horn 1,155 XP

Armor XP is 7 XP per ingot in the recipe.

Silver Armor (requires Combat 25 to wear)

Piece Smithing level Materials XP
Helmet 24 80 Silver Ingots + 60 Molten Rock + 15 Brute Horn 560 XP
Body 30 100 Silver Ingots + 80 Molten Rock + 25 Brute Horn 700 XP
Legguards 28 75 Silver Ingots + 70 Molten Rock + 25 Brute Horn 525 XP
Boots 26 40 Silver Ingots + 20 Molten Rock + 10 Brute Horn 280 XP
Full set 295 Silver Ingots + 230 Molten Rock + 75 Brute Horn 2,065 XP

Armor durability: 2,500 uses per piece (rebalanced from 1,000 in a 2026-08-31 update) — each worn piece spends 1 durability per hit taken. Repair cost is roughly 60% of the original craft cost, scaled to damage taken (minimum 1 ingot).

Batch Crafting

Update: The forge supports batch crafting for smelting — pick a quantity (×1, ×5, or ×10) and the anvil works through it automatically instead of requiring a click per craft.
  • Batching applies to stackable smelts; forged tools and armor craft one per request.
  • Each unit takes roughly 1 second — a ×10 batch of smelting takes roughly 10 seconds.
  • If materials run out mid-batch, crafting stops and tells you — no partial-consumption surprises.
  • Closing the forge window cancels anything not yet started, at no material cost.

Bank Stacking

Identical tools, swords, and armor pieces now stack in the bank — up to 10,000 per stack. Only true matches stack (same item, same durability/wear level), so no durability data is lost by stacking. Right-click a stack to split it out one piece at a time. Carried bags are unaffected — gear still takes one slot each out in the world.

The Guild Bank also accepts gear as of a recent Guilds update — swords, armor, pickaxes, and axes can now be deposited alongside gold and materials, with wear preserved exactly as deposited and same-condition items stacking the same way as a personal bank.

Marketplace Restrictions

Only undamaged tools and armor can be listed or traded on the Marketplace, since durability isn't visible in listing or trade UI. Repair at Grimjaw or Harun to restore a piece to "like new" before trading it.

Tips

  • Smelt ingots in bulk before forging sessions — at about 1 second per ingot with ×10 batching, stockpiling is nearly instant now compared to the old 30-second rate.
  • Iron and Silver tools require reaching the relevant Smithing level before you can forge them — level up gradually through Copper tools/armor first.
  • Armor grants real XP on craft, so a full set is worth forging for the XP even if you don't plan to wear it yet.
  • Keep gear undamaged if you intend to trade or sell it — repair before listing.
  • Don't confuse Starter sword's low 5 damage for a bug — it's an intentional correction meant to make the Copper upgrade feel meaningful.
  • Tool tiers buy swing speed only — pick the tier your Smithing level allows, but don't expect bigger yields or more XP per gather.
Skills of Kintara
GatheringWoodcutting  ·  Mining  ·  Fishing
ProductionCooking  ·  Smithing
CombatCombat